Parallel trends

Guide for cdid 1.0.0.0 (Stata). Recorded examples retain their stated versions.

On this page

In chained difference-in-differences (cdid, Bellégo, Benatia and Dortet-Bernadet 2025; Callaway and Sant’Anna 2021), identifying treatment effects requires assuming that, in the absence of treatment, treated and control cohorts would have followed parallel average outcome trajectories conditional on covariates $X_i$.

In Stata, four options govern how parallel trends and pre-treatment comparisons are defined:

  • ptassumption(post|ctrl|all) (default post): selects the parallel-trends restrictions imposed in the GMM system; ctrl adds common trends among the eligible control cohorts, and all common trends of the target and control cohorts, from ptstart(),
  • ptstart(#): specifies the common calendar start date, required with ptassumption(all), optional with ptassumption(ctrl) (where it defaults to the first study date), and not allowed with ptassumption(post),
  • anticipation(#) (default 0): sets the number of pre-treatment calendar periods in which units may anticipate treatment, fixing each cohort’s reference period $r(g)$ at the latest study date $d$ with $d < g - \text{anticipation}$ ($g - 1 - \text{anticipation}$ when the dates are consecutive integers),
  • baseperiod(varying|universal) (default varying): independently controls how unrestricted pre-treatment comparisons (role == "pre") are parameterized and reported.

1. Post-treatment parallel trends (ptassumption(post), default)

Under ptassumption(post) (PT-post), conditional parallel trends are assumed from each cohort’s reference period $r(g)$ onward. Specifically, for every post-reference date pair $(s, t)$ with $r(g) \le s < t$ and control pool $K$:

$$E[Y_t(0) - Y_s(0) \mid X, G = g] = E[Y_t(0) - Y_s(0) \mid X, G \in K]$$

What about date pairs touching periods before $r(g)$?

  • Under ptassumption(post), pre-reference untreated differentials $\delta_{g, d \to d+1}$ for $d < r(g)$ are unrestricted free parameters in the GMM system.
  • Under the other assumptions on the comparisons, on observation and on the adjustment models, earlier differentials can enter the model without being restricted to zero. This is a statement about identification in the population, not about exact invariance in finite samples.

Comparisons through earlier dates under ptassumption(post)

Even though pre-reference differentials are unrestricted under ptassumption(post), two-date comparisons starting before $r(g)$ are still used whenever their unrestricted differentials before the reference period cancel through an intermediate date:

  • Suppose cohort $g = 3$ has reference period $r(3) = 2$, and units are observed on pairs $(1, 2)$ and $(1, 3)$.
  • In the GMM design matrix $A$, the comparison on $(1, 2)$ loads on $\delta_{3, 1 \to 2}$, while the comparison on $(1, 3)$ loads on $\delta_{3, 1 \to 2} + \text{ATT}(3, 3)$.
  • Taking the difference between the two moments cancels $\delta_{3, 1 \to 2}$: $$E[Y_3 - Y_1] - E[Y_2 - Y_1] = E[Y_3 - Y_2]$$ and identifies $\text{ATT}(3, 3)$ without assuming parallel trends between $t = 1$ and $t = 2$.

2. Adding pre-reference restrictions (ptassumption(all) ptstart(#))

The Stata snippets on this page use the simulated panel and the global CDID_DEMO_BITERS created by Sections 0 and 1 of the hands-on do-file; run those sections first.

When domain knowledge justifies parallel trends starting at an earlier calendar date $t_{\text{start}}$ common to all cohorts, specify ptassumption(all) together with ptstart(#):

cdid y x_bin x_cont, ivar(id) time(period) gvar(first_treat) ///
    method(dr) controlgroup(nevertreated) ptassumption(all) ptstart(1) ///
    biters($CDID_DEMO_BITERS)

What ptassumption(all) ptstart(#) changes, and what it keeps unchanged:

  1. Keeps every PT-post condition and each cohort’s reference period $r(g)$: Post-treatment effects $\text{ATT}(g, t)$ ($t \ge g$) are still defined relative to each cohort’s reference period $r(g)$ ($t = 2$ for $g = 3$, $t = 4$ for $g = 5$).
  2. Constrains the differentials from ptstart(#) up to $r(g)$ to zero: Every differential on an untreated step between ptstart(#) and $r(g)$ is constrained to zero in the GMM design matrix $A$. As a result, a comparison from $t = 1$ to $t = 3$ for cohort $g = 3$ directly loads on $\text{ATT}(3, 3)$ without needing to subtract a separate $(1, 2)$ comparison.
  3. Remains a chained within-unit GMM estimator: ptassumption(all) adds zero restrictions on the differentials to the chained GMM system, which uses the same within-unit comparisons. It does not switch to a cross-sectional estimator, and it does not guarantee smaller standard errors in every cell or in every finite sample draw (How to compare precision, Add PT-all restrictions).
  4. Validation:
    • ptstart(#) is required with ptassumption(all) and must be one of the periods of the data.
    • ptstart(#) is not allowed with ptassumption(post).

Choosing ptstart(#)

Always choose ptassumption(all) and ptstart(#) substantively from institutional or domain knowledge before inspecting point estimates, standard errors, or pretrend test $p$-values. Data-mining ptstart(#) after viewing pretrend tests invalidates subsequent inference.

3. Base-period parameterization (baseperiod(varying|universal))

Separately from ptassumption(post|all), the option baseperiod(varying|universal) controls how unrestricted pre-treatment comparisons (role == "pre", where $t < g - \text{anticipation}$) are defined and reported in e(b):

  • baseperiod(varying) (default): Reports consecutive pre-treatment step comparisons (comparing each pre-treatment period $t$ to the immediately preceding period in the stored calendar).
  • baseperiod(universal): Reports every non-reference pre-treatment period $t$ relative to the cohort’s fixed reference period $r(g)$.

Crucially, pre-treatment cells (role == "pre") are never forced to zero in e(b) by ptassumption(all): under both ptassumption(post) and ptassumption(all), the reported pre-treatment cells remain direct unrestricted pre-period diagnostics.

4. How the row-space condition determines cell availability

The availability of each post-treatment effect is checked against the row space of the design. Pretreatment cells, which are direct comparisons, have their own support rules. Unsupported cells stay in the results with missing estimates and inference and a stated reason; e(b) holds only the available estimates, mapped to cells by e(coef_map). Use cdid_diagnostics, detail or cdid_export, type(cells) to see every cell. Regularizing the covariance cannot create support.

5. Pretrend tests under each choice

  • Unconditional joint Wald pretrend test (e(wald_statistic), e(wald_df), e(wald_p)): Jointly tests that all unrestricted pretreatment cells (role == "pre") equal zero. Because role == "pre" cells remain unrestricted under ptassumption(all), the Wald test evaluates the exact same unrestricted pre-period null under both ptassumption(post) and ptassumption(all).
  • Standalone conditional pretrend test (cdid_pretest): Tests that conditional pre-treatment mean comparisons equal zero across the covariate distribution on $F$ (r(CvM), r(CvMcval), r(CvMpval)). cdid_pretest evaluates direct pre-treatment pairs and therefore has no ptassumption() or ptstart() options (Inference).

6. Example

Section 3c of the hands-on do-file estimates the model under PT-all from period 1:

cdid y x_bin x_cont, ivar(id) time(period) gvar(first_treat) ///
    method(dr) controlgroup(nevertreated) ptassumption(all) ptstart(1) ///
    biters($CDID_DEMO_BITERS)

ptstart() names one of the periods of the data. PT-all leaves the pretreatment cells, which serve as diagnostics, unrestricted. See Add PT-all restrictions for an example in which PT-all is false.


Reading path, step 13 of 22 · Previous: Impute actual changes for missing outcomes · Next: Add PT-all restrictions

Guide home · Package overview

View this page at its source version · Report a problem